Scientists Map Hidden Ways Humans Are Reshaping Ecosystems Through Animal Behavior

Our framework maps how human activities change animal behavior, which can cascade through ecosystems to affect fundamental processes like nutrient cycling and pathogen transfer. We synthesized existing literature and theory to create a novel framework mapping pathways from human impacts through behavioral changes to ecosystem functions.

We found that human activities affect animal behavior through four distinct mechanisms. We change population densities through hunting and culling. We create top-down effects by acting as 'super predators'—triggering fear responses that can differ from and exceed those caused by natural predators. We alter resource availability through intentional feeding or habitat destruction. And we modify physical environments through noise, light, chemical pollution, and habitat structure changes. These behavioral shifts can affect critical ecosystem functions including nutrient cycling, primary productivity, pathogen transfer, and habitat provision.

What struck us most was how few studies actually documented the complete pathway from human impact through behavioral change to ecosystem consequences. The literature is full of papers showing that construction noise makes birds sing differently, or that boat traffic changes whale movement patterns, but almost nobody follows up to see if these behavioral changes translate into measurable ecological effects.

"These behavioral shifts can affect critical ecosystem functions including nutrient cycling, primary productivity, pathogen transfer, and habitat provision."

This knowledge gap has serious implications for conservation management. Without understanding these pathways, we risk wasting resources on mitigating behavioral effects that ultimately have little ecological relevance. Conversely, we might overlook important drivers of ecosystem change not addressed through traditional management strategies.

Our framework can help prioritize which human-induced behavioral changes deserve immediate attention and which might be ecological dead ends.

Citation

Wilson, Margaret W.; Ridlon, April D.; Gaynor, Kaitlyn M.; Gaines, Steven D.; Stier, Adrian C.; Halpern, Benjamin S. (2020). Ecological impacts of human‐induced animal behaviour change. Ecology Letters.

Read the full paper